A Shameful Decision
February 19, 2007 – 4:04 pmLast year Donetsk oligarch Renat Akhmetov began to go public for the first time and to show a ‘human’ side to his public image. At a press conference he was asked what position he would like to have in the newly elected parliament to which he was elected for the fist time the Party of Regions? To which his reply was ‘head of the Committee on Organized Crime’. This failed attempt at cracking a joke did not go down very well among the journalists who were present.
Today, reading the Ukrainian news I thought there was another attempt at a bad joke. I read that the Yaroslav Mudry medal, third class, has been awarded to Mykhailo Potebenko for ‘his great personal contribution to the building of a law abiding state, the strengthening of legality and law abiding, and his long years of conscientious toil on the occasion of his 70th birthday’.
Thinking this was another attempt at a bad joke, I immediately thought of my own contributions to Ukraine’s comedy. Yuriy Krawchenko should be awarded a posthumous medal for his dedicated contribution to transforming Ukraine’s police force into a professional force, to the Party of Regions for its incessant devotion to upholding the concept of free elections, to Viktor Medvedchuk for his single-handled contribution to expanding media freedom, to Volodymyr Lytvyn for his campaign to remove plagiarism, to Leonid Kuchma for his contribution to enriching Ukraine’s language and, we should not forget, to Viktor Yushchenko for his contribution to stressing the importance of punctuality and decisiveness in the lives of Ukrainian citizens.
Joking aside, it is increasingly difficult to understand the policies undertaken by President Yushchenko as they are devoid of rationale, logic, vision and explanation. This, by the way, is not just my own view but that of Ukrainians visiting Washington and of those who follow Ukraine in this city.
His decision to award Potebenko a state medal is a disgrace and an insult to murdered journalist Heorhiy Gngadze and to Grand Prince Yaroslav Wise, who introduced Ukraine’s first book of laws, Ruska Pravda in the eleventh century. Potebenko would be disgraced in any Western democracy for covering up widespread, high level abuse of office when he was Prosecutor. His actions as Prosecutor during the investigation of the murder of Gongadze were a sham meant only to deflect blame away President Kuchma.
In the 2002 elections, Potebenko was elected on the Communist Party list. He was quickly expelled because he was a Kuchma-loyalist Trojan horse who provided the additional vote that permitted Lytvyn to be elected parliamentary chairman with 226 votes.
I am currently writing a book on Ukrainian politics from Kuchmagate to the Orange Revolution which has led me to re-read some of my files from that period. In re-reading the same files – after two years of the Yushchenko administration – I was struck to find different information than when I initially compiled the files in 2000-2003.
The files provide clues as to the granting of the award to Potebenko that lies in Yushchenko’s unwillingness to ever be a revolutionary or an oppositionist. In 2000-2001, Yushchenko and those political forces who joined Our Ukraine in 2002, refused to support the impeachment of Kuchma for which there was ample evidence that stretched beyond Gongadze’s murder. Kuchma’s representative in parliament, Roman Besmertnyi, threatened parliament with a state of emergency if it voted to impeach Kuchma.
Besmertnyi joined Our Ukraine in 2001 as somebody with a similar world view to Yushchenko; namely, that Our Ukraine should be a constructive (loyal) opposition that distanced itself from what they considered to be ‘hardliners’ (Yulia Tymoshenko). Yushchenko and Our Ukraine blamed Ukraine’s problems not on the ‘Good Tsar’ (Kuchma) but on the ‘Boyars’ (Krawchenko, Medvedchuk). In 2002 and again in 2006, Yushchenko and Our Ukraine chose to create a parliamentary coalition with pro-Kuchma loyalists rather than cooperate with the opposition and Orange partners in the Tymoshenko bloc and Socialists.
Yushchenko and Our Ukraine were forced to become temporary revolutionaries in 2004 against their will and natural inclinations. Their lack of revolutionary zeal can be seen in their weak reform programme, continued ‘Yuliaphobia’ and preference for reaching a deal with the Party of Regions.
In 2002-2003, Yushchenko and Our Ukraine fluctuated between working with the opposition and calling for a dialogue with the authorities. During the Orange Revolution, Yushchenko supported the opportunity of dialogue during the round table negotiations where he became what he achieved what he had always sought; namely, Kuchma’s anointed successor as the compromise reached at the dialogue guaranteed Yushchenko’s election on 26 December 2004. Tymoshenko, who had always been against dialogue with the ‘criminal’ authorities, was prevented from attending the round table negotiations.
The compromise reached at the dialogue that Yushchenko had always sought with the authorities has undermined his presidency. First, Prime Minister Yanukovych is the main beneficiary of constitutional reforms and polls show that they believe he is in charge of the country.
Second, the immunity granted to Kuchma came easily to Yushchenko and Our Ukraine as they had never condemned his abuse of office or his involvement in Gongadze’s murder. The Ukrainian book by M.I. Melnyk, Criminal Responsibility for Crimes against Election Laws, shows that almost all of the 1,297 cases brought by the Prosecutor in the 2004 presidential elections were against those executing fraud and not those who organized the fraud. The courts only found 265 guilty but gave them light sentences, such as suspended sentences, or they received amnesty.
The organizers are today in charge of Ukraine. Potebenko is a state hero. Could somebody please remind me again who won the 2004 elections?
16 Responses to “A Shameful Decision”
it is just the proof that Youshenko is only next oligarh and he is unable to conduct reforms. Ukraine is not Russia, where Putin can do almost whatever he wants with oligarhs. Ukraine is still schizophrenic country, where people contradict their own words. It is just ukrainian “baradak” and the way of ordinary life as well as political tradition.
By Justine on Feb 20, 2007
“Ukraine is not Russia, where Putin can do almost whatever he wants with oligarhs…”
I do not think that this notion is true. Look at what he is doing with Abromovich, Mikhail Fridman, Potemkin and others. Lives of these people do not differ from the lives of most of Ukrainian oligarchs, neither Russian state in any way is less liberal toward them than Ukrainian one.
Yes, for political reasons and these reasons only he exiled Beresovsky and Gusinksy to Europe, and those who preferred to stay in the country and dared to challenge his authority, as Khodorkovsky has done, were sent to less agreeable places in Siberia.
By Claire on Feb 23, 2007
So will you be receiving a visit from Yuliya Timoshenko?
It looks like at the onset that her visit is getting some decent press.
http://news.google.com/?ie=UTF-8&ncl=1113792885&hl=en
They are playing off the official unpopularity of Russia in the US after Putin’s remarks…
dlw
By dlw on Feb 24, 2007
Contrary to those visitors from Ukraine living in what they think to be a “de-ideologized” pos-communist world, you, Taras should perfectly understand that the actions of Youschenko and his party, namely their disgust for any state interventions in economy and society and their willingness to clinch a deal with a quite liberal-minded Party of Regions, is dictated by ideoligical considerations and has little to do with Youshenko’s personal traits. That is the primary reason for their inabilty and lack of desire to form a stable alliance with Youlia, newly accepted member of the Socialist International. That is Youlia’s desire to bring more State which is the main cause of “Youliaphobia” expressed by many Youshenko’s supporters. What I would like to say is not that the “personal factor” has no role in contemporary Ukrainian politics, but that in your writings, Dr Kuzio, you tend to put too much emphasis on it, certainly at the expense of other factors, which could be of even bigger importance.
2 Justine,
Mr Putin’s autonomy vis-Ã -vis the oligarchs faces with serious limits. Not only Abramovich and other oligarchs who have succeeded in operating a distinction between “high politics” and “low politics”, therefore leaving to “Caseser Caeserevo” are doing very well, but their number during the years of the Putin’s rule has more than doubled – the number of those with personnal fortune of 1 bln USD has increased from 9 to 20.
Just consider the evolution of inequalities in modern Russia: with its Gini index being equal to 45, together with Bresil, Russia still is the country with the most uneven distribution of revenues in the world.
On the contrary, Ukraine, with its Gini ceffficient equal to 29, comes close to Continental European countries like Germnay, and, from the beginning of the years 2000, appears to be on its ways to social democracy, in spite of the difficulties, often exaggerated by local media, which you tend to perceive as “bardak”.
By Sergiy on Feb 26, 2007
why would kutchma be given immunity against the murder anyway?
By andrew Lyczmanenko on Mar 19, 2007
Totally agree
By MattGar on May 17, 2007
Great post! Much appreciated
By Temporary Inbox on Jul 16, 2009
adult xxx movies
lesbian toilet slaves
super models naked
does christina aguilera have her tits pierced
asian model galleries
nude african men
older amateur
teen virgin sex
sex surrogates
xxx pics free
stretching pussy
really small boobs
cartoon incest
young topless teens
grandma lesbians
ebony cum shot
lesbian swingers
young marble giants
oral sex trailers
porn star august
By Aron on Feb 10, 2010
la brims gang
redline rl340 prices
free yahoo firewall protection
anais martinez nude fotos
evenflo model 3591288p1
nguoi dep cua toi
download kenshin ai mugen
short chinese bob pictures
barns and knoble bookstore
edible creations coupon
does raven symone married
l_s magazine bbs
ananga ranga men and women
carson piere scott department store chicago
inverted angle bob photo
rifle trajectory charts
craigs list cars columbus ohio
jeana keough nude pics
2008 physic predctions
pokemoncrater v8 login
By Kir on Feb 14, 2010
belks online catalog
mfx kiss and vomit porn
symptoms of cracked tailbone
learning russian printable
candid descuidos
the examples of waka poems
all haircut pictures
ls charming angels
keeping bobhaircuts long
amar sin limit novela
rg model 40 38 special revolver
full body massagevideo
www wal mart benfit com
edith labelle nude
jovensitas calientes tanga
mamacitas mexicanas
naughty coco lola
boggle descramble
toddler bloody stool softener
benni hanna restaurant georgia
By Bill on Mar 31, 2010
brandsmart 36 gas range
andrea barber died anorexia
bombshell lyrics 19 and crazy
bob hairstyles with weaves
black cock smokers superhead
acls question and answer
black and cream long hair daschund pictures
aseel bantam chicks
box chevy fest
2pac unreleased songs
boys humping girls in the puzzle
bursa gun manufacturer
9 trey gangster knowledge
alex real housewives nude
38 derringer pics and prices
ammonia smell in discharge while pregnant
brooke burke playboy video shoot
auto decoders
celebrity death morgue
astra model 1916
By Heel on Apr 18, 2010
ar 15 silencer plans
azlyrics request
acute liver failer mayo clinic com
danica patrick pussy
americanas cojiendo con perros
antique colt 38 police pistol values
all time leading nfl rushers 2010
45 70 derringer
big amaturenipples
ambassadeur parts online
300 wsm vs 338 lapua
altair jarabo maxim
boondocks saints 2 quotes
13 lbs 10 oz in kilograms
centigrades to far converter
best brush for styling angled bob
car fetish girls smoke tires
bruised coccyx
ar 15 zeroing chart
bernie and phil furniture coupon code
By Aron on Apr 27, 2010
1 kg equals how many pounds
braun thermoscan 6200 manual
angelawarren nude picture
boy penis masterbate
1990 gm o2 wiring
african amercian braiding hair styles
125g of flour is how many cups
armstrong wellington ceiling tiles
310 c dozer parts
ac moore weekly specials
celebritylook alike
carson piere scott com
braless sheer
allstateatwork com mybenefits
blue pitbull mcallen texas
building backyard fire pits cinder blocks
arabic style furniture dealer houston
eaa bunda shotgun
andis fades
big black bootty nude
By Dominic on Apr 27, 2010
winnie footjob
donks for sale
kwentong pantasya sagad bugso
rotiserie cookers in pennsylvania
premade neopets anime shop layouts
husky pro compressor specs
yamaha four wheelers
fram oil filters for tractors
prno casero
kerry byron mythbusters
download mopar scape 3
example of simile poem poet
tiajuana girls
turkey roasting bags
bokon tosh iran
shinny lines on penis head
pornstar felsha
da pope footwork juke
gulfstream race track results park
st louis craigslist missouri
By Arnie on May 4, 2010
I’m a blogger me personally and I observed your article to generally be extremely fascinating and special. Great job for this great article, and I’ve just became subscribed for any blog. Hope you do the identical for me.
By water damage pasadena on Jan 5, 2011
Lot of quality content i see on blog.taraskuzio.net
motorola droid razr
By motorola-droid-razr on Nov 13, 2011